Annuities are often marketed as a retirement solution because they offer guaranteed income streams that can last a lifetime. However, there are several factors to consider whether an annuity is truly the “best” option. It depends on your financial situation, income needs, risk tolerance and long-term goals. For many, the most effective strategy may combine an annuity with other income-producing assets for a diversified retirement plan.
A financial advisor can help you decide whether an annuity might complement your retirement portfolio.
Annuity Basics
An annuity is a financial contract between an individual and an insurance company. In exchange for a specified payment up front, the insurance company will make periodic payments to the retiree. This arrangement is great for those seeking predictable income in retirement. It offers protection against outliving their assets, commonly referred to as longevity risk.
Earnings growth within an annuity is also typically tax-deferred until withdrawals begin. This allows potential compounding over time without immediate tax consequences. Many annuity products also allow for customization, offering features such as inflation protection, enhanced death benefits, or spousal income options.
However, there are pros and cons of annuities. Certain types can carry high fees, including administrative costs, mortality and expense charges, and additional fees for optional riders. Liquidity can also be a concern, as accessing the invested principal can be costly or complicated. Moreover, annuity contracts, often filled with fine print and nuanced terms, are more complex than other retirement solutions.
For retirees, specific types of annuities tend to be more suitable than others. For example:
- Immediate fixed annuities generate stable income shortly after the initial investment. This is useful for covering essential retirement expenses.
- Deferred income annuities delay payments to provide income later in retirement.
- Fixed indexed annuities offer the potential for modest growth. They’re tied to a market index that protects against downside losses. Great for those seeking market exposure without risking principal.
Annuity Alternatives
While annuities offer valuable features for retirees seeking guaranteed income, they are far from the only solution available. Choosing between an annuity and alternative options — or integrating both into a retirement plan — depends largely on individual goals, risk tolerance, and income needs.
401(k)s and IRAs
Retirement accounts such as 401(k)s and IRAs remain the cornerstone of retirement savings for many Americans. Both allow workers to accumulate tax-advantaged savings throughout their careers. Contributions may be made on a pre-tax basis (traditional accounts) or post-tax (Roth IRA accounts). Investments grow tax-deferred or, in the case of Roth accounts, potentially tax-free. Many 401(k) plans also feature employer matching contributions, which can significantly boost retirement savings.
Individual Portfolios
A portfolio of stocks, bonds, mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and other assets offers more control than an annuity. Investors can adjust their allocations based on changing market conditions, risk tolerance and income needs.
Equities within a portfolio can also provide long-term growth potential, which may outpace inflation over time. Unlike many annuities, which may cap upside gains or charge high fees, a self-managed investment portfolio can be tailored to changing goals without contractual limitations.
Retirement Income Funds
Retirement income funds are a more hands-off option for retirees who prefer professional management. These funds are structured to provide consistent payouts through a diversified mix of assets. This simplifies the income generation process while still offering diversification and potential for growth. They also allow greater flexibility if the retiree wants to change investment strategies or access principal, something annuities typically restrict.
Bonds
Bonds serve as a staple for many retirement income strategies. They offer predictable interest payments and the return of principal at maturity. Retirees can construct portfolios of bonds with staggered maturity dates, known as bond ladders, to provide steady income. Bonds, particularly government and high-grade corporate bonds, also tend to be less volatile than equities.
Unlike annuities, which bundle income guarantees with insurance features (and fees), bonds allow retirees to maintain ownership of their principal and have more flexibility in managing maturities and reinvestment. However, they lack the longevity risk protection annuities provide.
Certificates of Deposit (CDs)
CDs provide another predictable income source. They pay a fixed interest CD rate over a set period in exchange for meeting a certain deposit. CDs offer safety (they’re FDIC-insured) but may struggle to keep pace with inflation, particularly in low-interest-rate environments. Early withdrawal penalties can reduce their appeal for retirees needing liquidity.
Compared to annuities, CDs offer simplicity and full principal protection without the complex fee structures often found in annuity products. However, they do not provide the guaranteed lifetime income or inflation riders that some annuities offer.
What to Consider
When evaluating what is better than an annuity for retirement, consider the following:
- Risk Tolerance: How much market volatility are you comfortable with? Annuities offer stability, but potentially at the cost of growth.
- Income Needs: Assess your essential expenses and how much guaranteed income you require.
- Fees and Expenses: Compare the costs of annuities, managed funds and other strategies.
- Tax Implications: Different retirement income sources have varying tax treatments. Planning withdrawals tax-efficiently can make a big difference.
- Liquidity Needs: Ensure you have access to enough liquid assets to cover emergencies or lifestyle changes.
A financial advisor can help you evaluate all the options and build a retirement plan designed to meet your individual needs.
Bottom Line
Annuities can play an important role in retirement planning by providing predictable income and reducing longevity risk. However, they are not the only, or necessarily the best, option for every retiree. Whether a 401(k), IRA, personal portfolio, or a mix of strategies is better than an annuity depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance and income needs. Most retirees will benefit from a diversified approach that combines different income sources for flexibility and security.
Tips for Retirement Planning
- A financial advisor can help you with your long-term retirement planning. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
- A retirement calculator can help you estimate how much you might need to save to have the retirement you need.
Photo credit: ©iStock.com/Rawpixel Ltd, ©iStock.com/South_agency, ©iStock.com/Rockaa
Read the full article here
